# Hanging a bob in an inertial frame

Suppose a bob is hanging from the ceiling of a car by a thread. The car is moving with a constant acceleration $a$ towards right. The thread is making an angle $x$ with the vertical. If we see from the frame of car we call say that the pseudo force balances the horizontal component of tension. Then how can we explain why the bob is fixed from the ground frame as there is no pseudo force in this case?

Physics Asked on November 11, 2021

In the car frame there is a pseudo force to explain why the bob hangs at rest at an angle to the vertical. The sum of forces is then zero. In the ground frame the bob is accelerating; this is explained by an unbalanced force in the direction of acceleration.

Answered by sammy gerbil on November 11, 2021

From the perspective of an observer from both frames one thing which is common is that the bob is inclined to the vertical making an angle $x$ from the pivoted point.

In the car frame, you are absolutely correct about the pseudo force. I am sure things are pretty clear for you in the non-inertial frame. So, most of my answer will cover calculations made for the bob's motion from the inertial frame.

Let $a_{b,g}$ and $a_{b,c}$ be the acceleration of the bob in the ground frame and car frame respectively.

$therefore vec a_{b,g}= vec a_{b,c}+vec a_c$

Since, $|vec a_{b,c}|=0$,

$vec a_{b,g}= vec a_c$ $tag 1$

From the ground, you will observe to bob to be accelerating (not fixed), with an acceleration equal to the acceleration of the car, $'a'$. One might ask why is the bob accelerating. The answer to this question comes into light when you realize that the bob is not completely vertical. The force that is imparting acceleration to the bob is the tension in the string.

Free body diagram of the bob :

In the horizontal :

$ma_x=Sigma F_x$

$ma=Tsin{x}$ $,(because Sigma F_x = Tsin{x}$)$tag 2$

In the vertical :

$ma_y=Sigma F_y$

but $a_y=0$,

$therefore Sigma F_y=0$

$mg-Tcos x=0 implies mg=Tcos x$ $tag 3$

Normally one would not be able to form equations of motion using Newton's laws for a body in a non-inertial frame. To make it possible all we have to do is to add a pseudo force in the FBD of the body. This allows us to use Newton's laws in non-intertial frames.

In the non-inertial frame, we just have to balance the pseudo force and the horizontal component of tension in order to satisfy the observation we make from the car's frame that the bob is stationary. Same goes for the vertical axis.

Answered by Mitchell on November 11, 2021

## Related Questions

### Is number of photons undefined for a classical EM wave?

4  Asked on December 26, 2020 by ruslan

### Can we feel the electrons which move from one object to other during rubbing which caused charge?

1  Asked on December 26, 2020 by bora-ramireddy

### Heisenberg representation: why position operator has no explicit time dependance?

1  Asked on December 26, 2020

### What happens to heat waste produced by energy generation?

4  Asked on December 26, 2020 by user27515

### Entropy reducing power generator

1  Asked on December 26, 2020 by dallas

### Energy of exciton formation in semiconductors

1  Asked on December 26, 2020 by aleksejus-pacalovas

### Why does water ($mathrm{H_2O}$) only have two distinct fluid phases?

4  Asked on December 26, 2020 by jn-lalinsk

### Can one force the octupole moments of a charge distribution (neutral and with vanishing dipole moment) to vanish using a suitable translation?

1  Asked on December 26, 2020 by emilio-pisanty

### Right-Angle Lever Paradox where does the ang. momentum go?

2  Asked on December 26, 2020

### Can Thevenin voltage ever be negative?

1  Asked on December 26, 2020 by user56220

### Variations wrt. Time Derivatives

3  Asked on December 26, 2020 by chip

### Deformable body under a force and a moment

0  Asked on December 26, 2020

### Is the pressure in a pipe equal the pressure in the tank?

1  Asked on December 26, 2020 by physicsguy123

### SDE with drift multiplied by telegraph like random process

1  Asked on December 26, 2020 by ernst

### Energy dependence in density functional theory

1  Asked on December 26, 2020

### Potential Energy of a System of Point Charges

0  Asked on December 25, 2020 by iamsecretlyflash

### How do two light beams, one squeezed in phase and the other in amplitude, superposed on a beamsplitter, result in an EPR entangled state?

0  Asked on December 25, 2020 by quantum-journalist

### Understanding the expression for spherical waves vs plane waves

1  Asked on December 25, 2020

### What does it mean to generate the full algebra of $SU(2)$ by commutation?

1  Asked on December 25, 2020 by asph

### Freedom in choosing elements/entries of an eigenvector

2  Asked on December 25, 2020 by geeth-chandra